Explainer · Moderate Voices of America(MVA)
Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Race, Pushing Democrats to 56 Seats
By Mark Evans
Fifteen days after Election Day, the last Senate race is decided — and it did not need the ranked-choice tabulation Alaska had scheduled for today. On Tuesday night, November 17, the Associated Press called the race for Democrat Mary Peltola after a new batch of absentee ballots pushed her past 50% of first-choice votes. She defeated two-term Republican Senator Dan Sullivan, and the new Democratic Senate majority will be 56 seats, not 55.
The race is close enough that it took two weeks to settle, and clear enough now that its shape is settled. Peltola leads by more than 12,000 first-choice votes. She cleared the outright-majority line on the first count, so no ballots are redistributed, no second choices are counted, and today’s tabulation does not happen.
Mississippi is decided
The other half of this story closed on Wednesday, November 11. The Associated Press called Mississippi for Democrat Scott Colom that evening, and Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith conceded in a video statement the same night.
At the time of the call, Colom led 473,336 votes to 468,667 — a margin of 4,669 — with independent Ty Pinkins at 20,234. The final official results, released by the Secretary of State’s office on November 13, widened it: Colom 479,404, Hyde-Smith 471,817, a margin of 7,587—counties certified by the November 13 deadline.
That result alone guarantees Democrats at least 55 Senate seats in January. Alaska makes it 56.
The Alaska count: Peltola crosses 50%
Alaska counts slowly, by design and by distance. On Monday evening, November 16, Peltola was still 52 votes short of an outright majority — 141,637 first-choice votes, 49.98%, against Sullivan’s 130,162. Tuesday night’s count changed that. The Division of Elections’ Tuesday-night report, with an estimated 99% of votes counted and 290,003 ballots included, shows:
- Mary Peltola (D): 144,302 first-choice votes, 50.12%
- Sen. Dan S. Sullivan (R, incumbent): 131,844, 45.80%
- Gerald L. Heikes (R): 6,105, roughly 2.1%
- Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.: 4,760, 1.65% — a retired Petersburg teacher who shares the senator’s name, not a relative
- Write-ins: 885
Peltola’s lead is 12,458 votes. The Associated Press called the race at about 10:19 p.m. ET on Tuesday, November 17, concluding Sullivan had no workable path. Peltola’s campaign declared victory on Saturday, November 14, before the call; Sullivan has not conceded. His campaign said Monday night that Alaskans deserve “a complete and accurate count, and we will let that process run its course until every legal vote gets counted and certified.”
The result is unofficial until the state certifies it on November 25, and it can be legally challenged until December 5. A small number of overseas absentee ballots can still arrive through Wednesday, November 18. Still, they cannot change the outcome on the numbers counted so far: Peltola’s lead of 12,458 is more than double Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.’s 4,760 votes.
Why no ranked-choice tabulation was needed
Alaska’s system, in plain terms: if no candidate finishes with more than half of first-choice votes, the last-place finisher is eliminated, and those voters’ ballots move to their next-ranked choice, repeating until two candidates remain and one is over 50%. If someone tops 50% of first-choice votes, they win outright, and no tabulation is needed.
That is what happened here. Peltola was 52 votes short on Monday’s count — close enough that Tuesday’s ballots could still put her over it, and they did. The tabulation scheduled for Wednesday, November 18, is therefore not run for this race.
The tabulation would have mattered if she had stayed under 50%. The roughly 11,500 ballots for Heikes, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., and write-ins would then have been redistributed on second choices—more than her lead —which is why the count mattered even with a five-figure gap. Preliminary ranking data reported by the Anchorage Daily News cut both ways: nearly 30% of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.’s voters ranked Peltola second, while about 16% ranked the senator second, and Heikes’ voters favored Sullivan.
Applied to the ballots counted so far, independent models of the full ranking file put Peltola ahead in a final round by roughly 10,000 votes — about 51.9% to 48.1% in one analysis of the cast-vote record, and 51.8% to 48.2% in another. Those models are now moot as a prediction; they are worth keeping only as a check that the first-count result and the ranked-choice result pointed the same way.
There is a second verdict in this race that is already in. On Friday, November 14, the Associated Press called Ballot Measure 2 — the attempt to repeal Alaska’s ranked-choice voting and open primaries — as rejected, by roughly 53.5% to 46.5%. Voters adopted the system in 2020, rejected a first repeal attempt in 2024 by fewer than 750 votes, and have now rejected a second one by a wider margin. The system that would have decided this Senate seat is one Alaskans have just chosen, twice, to keep.
The controversy, stated plainly
One part of this race should not be left out of an honest account. On October 28, The New York Times reported that aides to Peltola’s campaign and Democratic Senate campaign officials recruited candidates, including Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., to confuse voters with a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot. Peltola has denied being involved in any such scheme.
The Justice Department, urged on by President Trump, filed a lawsuit in late October seeking to delay certification if Peltola won by fewer votes than Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. received. That condition is not met: her lead of 12,458 votes is well over his 4,760, and the Juneau Independent reports the issue is now seemingly moot. Federal and state criminal investigations into the allegations are reported to be ongoing.
The numbers decide the seat; they do not settle the allegation. On the record, the second Sullivan’s vote total did not decide the race — even if all votes for him, for Heikes, and every write-in had gone to the senator instead, Peltola would still lead.
What 56 seats actually change
The size of the majority matters, but it does not change who runs the Senate — Democrats already hold that. What one seat changes is the tolerance for error:
- 51 votes decide most Senate business — confirming nominees and passing budget bills. At 56 seats, Democrats could lose five of their own and still win a 51–49 vote. At 55, they could lose four.
- 60 votes are needed to end a filibuster on most legislation. Neither 55 nor 56 reaches that number. A Peltola win narrows the gap to four votes instead of five; it does not close it.
- 67 votes are needed to override a presidential veto. Neither number is close. (1)
In other words, 56 is a stronger majority, not a different kind of majority. It gives the incoming leadership more room to lose votes from its own caucus and less need to find Republican votes to reach 60. It does not give Democrats the power to pass bills over a filibuster on their own, and it does not change what the president keeps either way — the veto, the pardon power, and executive orders.
Peltola also makes history twice over: the first Indigenous Alaskan elected to the U.S. Senate, and the first Democrat to win an Alaska Senate election since Mark Begich in 2008. She is also, with Senator-elect Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota, among the first two Native American women in the chamber.
What to watch
- Wednesday, November 18: the deadline for overseas absentee ballots to arrive. The ranked-choice tabulation scheduled for today is not needed for the Senate race.
- Tuesday, November 25: the state’s target date to certify the result. Legal challenges may be filed until December 5.
- January 3, 2027: the new Congress begins, with the Senate at 56–44.
The election is over everywhere else. In Alaska, the count is nearly over too — and it ended on the first count, not in a tabulation.