Divided Government Is a Feature, Not a Failure

Divided Government Is a Feature, Not a Failure

Opinion/Commentary · Moderate Voices of America

By the Editorial Board

United States Captol Bilding Dome Silhouette--stock illustration

The results are in, and Washington is divided again. Democrats won the House (257 seats to 171, with 7 races still uncalled as of November 18) and the Senate (56–44, flipping nine Republican seats, the most since 1958). Donald Trump remains president with the veto pen. No party can govern alone. This is a recipe for bipartisanship.
 
The usual reaction to this outcome is a sigh: gridlock, dysfunction, and that nothing will get done. That reaction is understandable, but it misunderstands what the system is for. Divided government is not what happens when American politics fails in any form. It is what the system was designed to produce, and if used well, the arrangement is most likely to give Americans laws that last.
 
Divided is better if you value durability and restraint. Nothing sweeping happens without both parties, which means nothing sweeping gets reversed the next cycle either. It stops overreach in both directions, which is the case the article makes.

Divided Government, what it means

Start with the arithmetic because the arithmetic is the argument.
In the Senate, Democrats hold 56 seats — the majority. That is enough to confirm nominees and pass budget bills, which need only 51 votes. It is not enough to end a filibuster, which takes 60, or to override a presidential veto, which takes 67. In the House, Democrats hold 257 seats — 33 short of the 290 needed to override a veto on their own.
 
So every bill that becomes law in the next two years will need one of two things: votes from both parties and the president’s signature, or a supermajority nobody has. That is not an accident of this election. It is the Constitution working as written: each branch can check the others, and none can move alone.

Advantage one: it stops overreach in both directions

A week ago, this page warned the new Democratic majority against mistaking a protest vote for a mandate, against pushing investigations-first, base legislation written to die by veto, and against confusing a majority for a movement. Divided government enforces that warning structurally. A Democratic Congress cannot pass its base’s wish list over a Republican president’s veto, and a Republican president cannot govern by executive order alone. At the same time, a Democratic Congress holds the power of the purse and the subpoena—its only advantage in this equation.
 
That guardrail is neutral, and it matters that it is. It would work the same way with the parties reversed. In 2019 and 2020, a Democratic House checked a Republican president and a Republican Senate; in 2011 through 2016, a Republican House checked a Democratic president. The parties change. The check does not.
 
This is the sense in which divided government protects voters from their own side as well as the other one. A party that wins an election always believes the public has endorsed its whole program. The public rarely has. In this election, voters said prices were too high, Washington was not listening, and the party in power had to go. That is a verdict on performance, not a blank check for the winners’ agenda. Divided government makes that distinction hard to ignore because the winners cannot act on it alone.
 

Advantage two: it forces laws to be built to last

The strongest laws in modern American history were written under divided government, and that is not a coincidence. A bill that needs votes from both parties has to survive contact with the other side’s objections, which usually makes it sturdier, and it cannot be repealed the next time one party wins an election, because repeal needs the same coalition.
 
The 1986 tax reform — the last complete rewrite of the tax code — passed with a Republican president and a Democratic House. Welfare reform in 1996 passed with a Democratic president and a Republican Congress. The 2012 deal that ended the fiscal-cliff standoff, the 2013 Ryan-Murray budget agreement, the U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade agreement in 2019, and the CARES Act in 2020, passed unanimously in the Senate at the start of the pandemic, were all products of divided government.
 
Compare that with what one-party government produces. Party-line bills pass on party-line votes and then live under a permanent threat of repeal. The Affordable Care Act survived a dozen repeal votes and a Supreme Court challenge; the individual provisions of the 2017 tax law were written to expire because they could not command a durable majority. Laws only one party wants are laws the next election can undo. Laws both parties had to agree on tend to stay.
 
That is the real promise of the next two years: not more laws, but longer-lived ones.
 

Advantage three: it makes both parties argue on the merits

When one party controls everything, the argument inside Washington is about loyalty: who is with the program and who is against it. When control is split, the argument has to be about the policy, because neither side can win without persuading some members of the other.
 
That is not a sentimental point. It is practical. A Democratic bill on prescription drug prices or housing supply has to win Republican votes in the Senate and a Republican president’s signature, which means it has to be written in a way Republicans can defend back home.
 
A Republican proposal on energy permitting or border enforcement has to win Democratic votes in the House, which means the same in reverse. The bills that emerge from that process are narrower than either party’s base would write and broader in support than either party could produce alone.

Tug-of-war USA Politics Political Division - stock illustration

The honest case against it

None of this claims that divided government always works. It does not, and the failures are familiar.
 
Gridlock is real. The 2013 shutdown lasted 16 days. The 2011 debt-ceiling standoff ended with the first-ever downgrade of American debt. Judges wait, ambassadors wait, and crises do not wait for Congress to finish negotiating with itself. A divided government can also produce performative conflict instead of deals: investigations staged for television, bills introduced to fail, each side more interested in blaming the other than in legislating.
 
And the public has never actually asked for this arrangement. Gallup’s polling on the question is blunt: in its 2020 survey, a record 41% of Americans said they preferred one party to control the presidency and Congress, 23% preferred divided control, and 32% said it made no difference. Preferences swing with partisanship: whichever party holds the White House, its supporters tend to favor unified control. So the case for divided government cannot rest on a popular mandate. There isn’t one.
 
It rests instead on outcomes. Divided government is the arrangement under which the country has, more often than not, produced its most durable legislation, and under which neither party can mistake a single election for permission to remake the country in its image.
 
One more caution: divided government does not guarantee moderation. It guarantees that nothing happens without agreement, and agreement is a choice. The next two years could produce the kind of bargaining that built the 1986 tax code, or the kind of standoff that produced the 2013 shutdown. The structure sets the terms. The people in it decide which outcome we get.

What Americans should expect

So what should Americans expect from the next two years? Less than the campaign promises and more than the cynics predict if both sides do their jobs.
 
Expect fewer sweeping bills and more incremental deals. The issues that decided this election — prices, housing, health care costs — are the ones most likely to produce bipartisan legislation, because both parties campaigned on them and neither can solve them alone. Expect bills that are narrower than either party’s platform and more likely to survive the next election.
 
Expect the president to govern more by executive action and the courts to check him more often. That is what presidents do when Congress will not give them what they want, and it is what the judiciary is for. Executive orders are reversible by the next president; that is their weakness as policy and their virtue as a check.
 
Expect investigations and judge them by what they produce. Congress now has subpoena power in both chambers, and it will use it. The test is the one we set out last week: oversight that produces facts, documents, and fixes is accountability. Oversight that produces only hearings and headlines is theater. Americans should hold the new majority to that standard and hold the White House to answering real questions rather than dismissing them all.
 
Expect the budget fights to be the real test. Government funding deadlines and the debt limit are where divided government either produces a deal or produces a crisis. The 2011 standoff cost the country its AAA credit rating; the lesson is that brinkmanship has a price and the public pays it. Watch whether the two sides negotiate before the deadline or posture until after it.
 
Expect confirmations to move and expect the 2028 campaign to start immediately. Judges and nominees need only 51 Senate votes, so that machinery will keep running. And both parties will spend the next two years positioning for the next presidential election, which means every deal will be weighed against its campaign value. That is the hardest part of divided government: the incentive to cooperate is real, and the incentive to sabotage the other side’s record is just as real.
 
Expect to be the judge. The test of this Congress is not whether Washington is quiet or noisy. It is whether what passes can survive the next election, whether prices come down, whether bills pass with votes from both parties, and whether oversight produces accountability or only footage. Voters gave neither party everything. They gave each party enough to stop the other and just enough to force them to work together.
 
That is what the Framers had in mind when Madison wrote in Federalist No. 51 that “ambition must be made to counteract ambition.” Divided government is that sentence in practice. It is slower, messier, and more frustrating than one-party rule. It is also the arrangement most likely to leave Americans, two years from now, with laws still standing and a government that had to earn its keep.
 

Sources checked November 18, 2026 (ET): Associated Press seat counts — House Democrats 257, Republicans 171, 7 uncalled; Senate Democrats 56 (including two independents caucusing with Democrats), Republicans 44; Gallup Governance survey, October 2020 (41% prefer one-party control, 23% divided, 32% no difference); Federalist No. 51. Figures are unofficial until certification.
 
Editorial Board, Moderate Voices of America. Published by Global Moderates Forum, Inc., a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization. We do not endorse or oppose candidates for public office. Corrections and fairness challenges: info@moderatevoices.org.

Popular Category

Popular Category