When the Walls Come Down: What the Founders Feared and What Voters Saw

When the Walls Come Down: What the Founders Feared and What Voters Saw

Opinion/Commentary

 

America’s founding fathers were students of history, and they knew what happens when power gathers in one place. So they divided it. The executive would carry out the laws, the legislature would write them, and the judiciary would interpret them. Each branch was given its own powers and its own limits, and each was meant to check the others. The design has lasted more than two centuries, which is a remarkable run for any system of government.
 
But a design is only as strong as the people willing to work or defend it. During Donald Trump’s presidency, and especially his second term, many Americans came to believe that all three branches were failing at the same time, each in its own way. Here are the ways they were failing:
 

The executive reached. The second term saw a president who used executive authority more aggressively than any in recent memory. He governed by order and proclamation, tested the boundaries of what the office could do without Congress, and treated the limits on his power as suggestions:

 
  • Firing independent officials. Early in the term, Trump fired Democratic appointees at the FTC, the Merit Systems Protection Board and the NLRB without cause, challenging the Humphrey’s Executor precedent. He also fired the director of the Office of Government Ethics.
  • Dismantling agencies Congress created. Critics argue he refused to spend money Congress had appropriated and largely dismantled the Department of Education. Critics called the shuttering of USAID, which Congress had codified, unlawful.
  • Military force without Congress. Analysts described the boat strike campaign as a significant expansion of Article II power to use military force against private actors. On Iran, he relied on executive orders instead of the traditional War Powers Resolution process.
  • Power used for personal advantage. CNN’s analysis pointed to his Justice Department “forever” barring IRS audits of the president’s and his family’s past tax affairs.
  • Pressure on states. Reporting described federal funds being weaponized against states in unprecedented ways, according to experts.
 
The other view: Supporters see a historic effort to reclaim power from the “permanent bureaucratic class.” Even some scholars sympathetic to strong presidents have said parts of this are very aggressive and contested. That is a more measured claim than “unlawful.”
 

The judiciary made room. Courts exist to say where power ends. Yet in key moments, critics argued, the judiciary did the opposite. Rulings and emergency-docket decisions cleared the way for executive action, and the 2024 immunity decision loosened the idea that the president is bound like everyone else:

  • The emergency docket. The administration filed 42 emergency pleas to the Supreme Court, surpassing its entire first term. One study found the Court sided with the administration about 80 percent of the time.
  • Little explanation. Justice Sotomayor called the volume of appeals unprecedented in the Court’s history. Federal judges appointed by presidents of both parties said the Court should offer more explanation when it overturns lower courts. (1)
  • Dismantling the Department of Education. In a dissent, Justice Sotomayor said the Court’s decision gives the Executive the power to repeal statutes by firing those needed to carry them out. (2)
 
Defenders say the courts were following the law as written. But when the referee keeps widening the field, the players notice.
The other view, which matters here: The judiciary did not simply rubber-stamp everything. When the Court reviewed the president’s emergency-powers tariffs, it found his reliance on IEEPA unconstitutional.
 
The Justice Department argues the emergency docket reflects how often lower courts have blocked lawful policies without justification. Justice Alito has attributed the surge to presidents who govern by executive order, which produces lower-court rulings that move quickly to the Supreme Court.  
 
The legislature stepped back. This may be the most striking failure, because Congress is the branch the founders trusted most and watched most closely. Article I gives it the power of the purse, the power to declare war, the power to confirm appointments, and the power to investigate. Increasingly, Congress let those powers sit unused.
 
Lawmakers deferred to the White House, and oversight faded. Authority that belonged to the legislature moved to the executive, and few in Congress objected:
 
  • Tariffs. The Constitution gives Congress the power over duties, yet most Republican lawmakers were not ready to cross Trump on tariffs. House leaders even quietly surrendered their chamber’s ability to undo the tariffs on Mexico, Canada and China to spare members a hard vote.
  • War powers. In Venezuela, only two Republican senators voted with Democrats to require authorization. Other Republicans in Congress turned a blind eye. On Iran, war powers measures failed without enough Republican support, and the House failed even to bring one to a vote.
  • The power of the purse. A stopgap spending bill gave the administration wide discretion over how federal dollars are distributed.
  • Oversight. One analysis argued that subpoena power has gone unused and oversight has withered.
 
The other view: Republicans largely reject the idea that they have ceded oversight and spending powers. Scholars also note that Congress began handing tariff authority to presidents in the 1930s, so this erosion predates Trump. There were signs of pushback too, including seven Republican senators backing a bipartisan bill to check presidential tariff authority.
 
Why the combination matters: any one of these things would be a debate. A strong president has precedent, a deferential court has precedent, and a passive Congress has precedent. What alarmed so many people was all three happening together. The system is built on friction, with each branch pushing against the others. When the executive pushes, and the other two give way, the friction disappears, and the three branches begin to work as one unit. The founders spent a long summer in Philadelphia trying to prevent exactly that.
 
What voters did. That concern did not stay in op-eds and dinner-table arguments. It showed up on November 3, 2026. Democrats took control of both the House and the Senate, a result several outlets called a major rebuke to the president and his party. Voters have a way of restoring checks that institutions fail to enforce, and this looked like one.
 
What comes next. It would be a mistake to treat the election as the end of the story. Divided government gives Congress its leverage back, but leverage is useless if it isn’t used. The new majorities now face the same test the old ones failed: whether they will defend the institution’s powers or only the party’s interests. The same question applies to the courts and to whoever holds the White House next.
 
The founders didn’t build a machine that runs itself forever. They built one that needs people willing to hold their ground, whoever is in power.
 
The Constitution did its part. And Americans remain committed to the continual pursuit of a more perfect union.
 
Source:  1& 2. Tinder, J. (2026). Rule of law matters for fairness, trust. Indianapolis Business Journal, 47(12), 5B.
 
Nicholas A. Owoyemi, Moderate Voices of America. Published by Global Moderates Forum, Inc., a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization. We do not endorse or oppose candidates for public office. Corrections and fairness challenges: info@moderatevoices.org.

Popular Category

Popular Category